Fauda (فوضى) is an Arabic word that means “chaos” or “disorder.” It’s also the name of an Israeli streaming series that follows the foibles and failures of a special force’s unit. The show, which premiered in 2015, mixed the myth of the Shin Bet’s invincibility with tragi-comic mistakes often made because of the lead character, Doron Kavillio’s – played by Lior Raz – unhinged overconfidence in his ability to control a situation.
The use of an Arabic appellation for an Israeli show is a nod to the fact that the country sits within a sea of Arabic neighbors, including, prominently, Palestinians. The premiere occurred just six months after a previous, also devastating, 50-day war in Gaza. The underlying message seems to be, as long as conflicts in the region continue, Fauda will be an ongoing condition.
This season’s release occurs more than four years after the prior one, which left the main characters near-dead after being ambushed, Doron praying for the lives of his comrades. More importantly, it was created after October 7, 2023, during which at least 2,000 Israelis were killed, followed by the deaths of upwards of 74,000 Palestinians.
Season Five immediately claimed Netflix’s number one spot in Israel. It also surged across Arab nations, becoming the top show watched in Lebanon and in the Top 10 in Jordan, Qatar, United Arab Emirates, Bahrain, Oman, and Kuwait.
If a viewer was unaware of the context and reality on which the show is based it’d play as a compelling, albeit ruthless, sometimes hard to watch, action series. Season Five places Doron, a Die Hard-like indestructible hero, within a web of themes that, credible or not, attempt to explain Israel’s post-October 7 actions. It’s a somewhat warped window into a deeply wounded, traumatically stressed, national psyche, one grappling with what was done to it, how it responded and why. Sadly, it does not imagine a way out of present travails.
The opening scenes focus on an Arab father’s desire for tha’r (ثأر), or revenge, against the October 7 Gazans who killed his son. As with the series name, heavy – one might say, heavy-handed – use of an Arabic term places the action firmly within its larger Middle Eastern sensibility. Tha’r is not just simple revenge, like President Trump going after his purported enemies, but something much deeper: blood revenge or a blood feud. It’s an ancient concept, where a family or tribe is obliged to avenge the killing of one of their own, creating the conditions – the necessity – for vigilante “justice.”
Much of history has been marked by the struggle between tha’r and a more measured system of justice. Tha’r can result in mistaken or intentional harm to the innocent, because they’re wrongfully accused, punished solely due to their relationship to the perpetrator, or as part of “teaching” a larger lesson not to mess with the collective victim. It’s the rule of law versus the rule of the mob; power over diplomacy; heads on a pike. This season’s Fauda mirrors a swath of Israeli opinion that tha’r is completely justified by October 7 events, during which women and children were raped and slaughtered.
Questioned about why he killed an unarmed Maher Zeitoun, played by Amjad Bade, after Maher admits to massacring another main character’s family, Doron explains it was the way the confession was made, with a sneer, that triggered him. Though there’s no doubt about Maher’s guilt, this isn’t rationally meted-out justice. It’s tha’r; immediate, righteous, angry.
Whether a viewer gasps in satisfaction or horror when Doron shoots Maher in the head is a matter of perspective. Absent the reality of the present conflict, the scene could have taken place in an American Western, or Clint Eastwood movie.
Israelis’ mystification and sadness about Europe’s reaction to October 7 and the events thereafter – most recently in response to settler expansion in the West Bank – is depicted through a non-credible group of French people who volunteer for suicide missions on behalf of Hamas. Their avatar is Maher’s wife, Anne Aubert, played by Mélanie Laurent, stripped of any motivation to become an assassin other than to avenge her husband’s death; tha’r. Anne’s ultimate rejection of terrorism reflects a deeply held wish: if the world truly understood the extent of the atrocities committed by Hamas on October 7 it would side with Israel, with almost any military response justified.
Anne is convinced not to activate her suicide vest after locking eyes with a European-looking child, whose wide unblinking gaze beams civilian innocence. It’s a turning point for her character, and a missed opportunity for the show. A more subtle rendition would’ve placed the youngster more firmly in the Arabic realm, perhaps a talid or darker skin girl, signaling a broader embracing of the need to protect blameless lives.
That alternative storyline could have led to a final scene that reconciled tha’r with the imperative for civilized justice. A Central Intelligence Agency operative, with a long-term relationship with the Shin Bet, including fighting side-by-side in bloody battles, approaches a scarred Doron, puts a hand on his shoulder, and says, gently but firmly, “enough, brother.” Doron looks fiercely back, fists clenched, ready to fight, then softens, and collapses, crying, into the CIA agent’s arms.
Of course, such a scene would be near fantasy in today’s world, where America more often plays the role of impatient bully, throwing punches without aim, withdrawing from fights we start before they’re finished.
Still, what’s missing from Fauda, and from reality, is a meaningful pause to acknowledge Israel’s pain, the context in which it exists, and its legitimate fears of future harm. Then, an empathetic but firm ushering to a different place, where all civilians – including immigrants throughout the world – are fully protected and respected, rule of law prevails, and anger is announced and reconciled through measured words, not unhinged rants or angry deeds. There’s an Arabic word for that as well: salām (سَلام).
